I try not to judge children's books to harshly, for the most part. Whenever you are writing about something in a way that is supposed to be simplistic but also will grab the attention of a child, it can be hard to avoid images or texts that some may see as stereotypical or even racist. I think both the stories that we read were wonderful, especially the first one, but it is still important to take the discussion further. Perhaps you could ask the child afterward, "Where do you think this story took place? What is it like there? What are the people like?" And then help them to understand not only how they are different from the child, but also how they are alike. For example, in the first story, you could ask, "Why do you think Ahmed writes his name so differently from how we would write it?" or, "Do you think that everyone in Cairo dresses this way?" Reading to children is important, but it is only a small step in their development. If there is no discussion about the issues, the story may be remembered for it's bright colors, and nothing more.
I thought I would include some books on here that are different than what most of us think of when we are talking about children's literature:
I remember reading this book in elementary school. It's about a boy learning about his grandfather and the Vietnam War. I don't remember much about it, except it made me kind of sad and I wanted to go look at the wall.
This book tells the story of a family going through a divorce, and how although it is difficult, Dinah's parents still love her, and although things are changing, many things will be the same. My cousin's had a book very similar to this one when we were growing up. I remember it scared me but also helped me understand what they were going through.
This is a story about four animals that live together, but then the fox dies. The book talks about remembering all the wonderful things about Fox, and about how that keeps him with the other animals in their hearts. I also had a book similar to this one growing up. I don't remember when it was originally bought for me, but I do remember reading it and being just... mad. So I guess it moved me on to that second stage of grief! Oh well...
Some of the best new books deal with different families...
Hey, terrific post! I agree about the many great children's books and the importance of discussion. I think they can be used for discussion of adults, too. Of course, including college students.
ReplyDeleteI love children stories.. Sometimes you learn more from a simple children book than a mature book..
ReplyDeleteI love that you found these childrens books. i would definately use these books in my classroom!
ReplyDeleteGreat posts Kristen:)
my favorite book of all time has to be good night moon or one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish. I am pretty sure these stories have way more of an impact on a devoloping mind than an already developed one and if tied together with foreign customs? sounds like a recipe for successful understanding of the world and its people as a whole.
ReplyDelete